this happened to one of my wheels, but sort of different. some tire place totally fucked up one Enkei Phallnex 18x 10.5 while putting on a Nitto 555. So when they accidentally "machiened" my polished lip, they offered me a brand new one at no cost to me. Sweet. I still have the new one in the box W/new centerpiece(badge). You could barely tell the existing one was fucked up!